Cannabis in the Caribbean, Part I: Change is Coming
Laws are loosening and investors are interested, but who will reap the benefits?
Published on Dec 3, 2019 6:55AM EST Caribbean
LA native, graduated from Columbia Journalism School after working in education for several years. Her work has also appeared in La Opinión, the Columbia Journalism Review, and La Prensa Gráfica.
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
- Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
This is the first of two parts. The second will be published tomorrow.
Cannabis reform is picking up momentum in the Caribbean.
In recent years, jurisdictions throughout the area have softened their stance on the plant, largely through policies that have decriminalized simple possession and established robust programs for medical cannabis use and sales.
The trend began in Jamaica, which set off a chain reaction in 2015. That year, the island nation passed a law that decriminalizes possession of up to about fifty-six grams (two ounces) of cannabis, allows for the home cultivation of up to five plants, and establishes an agency to regulate medical use.
In 2016, the Cayman Islands followed suit, approving imports and sales of cannabis extracts and tinctures.
Then, in 2017, Bermuda amended its Misuse of Drugs Act, effectively decriminalizing the possession of less than seven grams. In this same vein, Antigua and Barbuda approved the home cultivation of up to four plants and decriminalized the possession of up to fifteen grams last year. The country also expunged convictions for possession at or under these amounts, and is looking to regulate production for medical and religious purposes.
And that’s just a part of the story. In 2018, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines moved to create a legal medical cannabis industry and began to issue licenses for commercial cultivation in July of this year. Similarly, last November, the Prime Minister of Dominica called for the decriminalization of simple possession.
The government of Saint Kitts and Nevis is advancing legislation, which, according to the country’s Prime Minister, could amend the “blanket criminalization of cannabis,” potentially expunge past convictions, and establish a regime for the medical use of cannabis.
And last month, Cannabis Wire covered that Trinidad and Tobago Attorney General Faris Al Rawi introduced two bills for debate in the House of Representatives: the Cannabis Control Bill and the Dangerous Drugs (Amendment) Bill. While specifics remain unclear, the package of legislation will regulate the consumption, production, and distribution of cannabis, while establishing the framework for an industry.
So things are changing. But who stands to benefit from these developments? And, more specifically, how are they shaping the lives of local residents?
The Caribbean Community (CARICOM), a coalition of twenty countries stretching from the Bahamas to Belize to Guyana, offers a lens into such questions, and would like to help shape the answers to them.
Back in 2014, CARICOM heads of government convened in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, where they created a commission to explore the possibility of cannabis policy reform. According to Rose-Marie Belle Antoine, the legal scholar and international consultant from the University of the West Indies who chairs the Commission, the heads of government “were deeply concerned that thousands of young persons throughout the region had suffered incarceration for marijuana use.” The inconsistent application of the law, Antoine added, had “led to deep resentment and non-cooperation with law enforcement agencies.”
Then, four years later, in 2018, the Commission—formally called the CARICOM Regional Commission on Marijuana—released a report that suggested additional reasons for loosening up on cannabis. First of all was the chance for economic progress and jobs. “There was also a concern,” it said, “that without action, the region could be left behind because of fast-paced global trends toward law reform.”
Try C-Wire Plus for $1.
But there were other concerns as well. As, Antoine wrote, “An important part of the Commission’s mandate was to undertake national consultations in Member States to harness the views of the CARICOM public.” As a result, commission members and policymakers got an earful. They “attended packed public meetings” in nine countries throughout the region, the report said, where stakeholders of all kinds spoke to broad issues—“moving beyond the narrow constraints of medical marijuana, to embrace notions of social justice, human rights, economics, regional hegemony and their right to health.”
The CARICOM Vision
Broadly, the proponents of cannabis policy reform mostly talk of two goals—health and development. They readily point out that patients need access to affordable medicine. They also argue that revenue from the medical cannabis industry can spur economic progress in the Caribbean.
While on the campaign trail, for instance, Albert Bryan Jr., governor of the US Virgin Islands (which legalized medical cannabis late last year), said that he believed “a properly regulated medicinal cannabis industry” could both “provide relief to those seeking alternatives to conventional medicine” and “be an economic driver attracting new revenues.” Similarly, the 2018 CARICOM Report on cannabis stated that “prohibition is preventing the region from taking advantage of the economic opportunities in the cannabis industry and medical research,” in addition to impeding access “to medicine that can heal more effectively and cheaply than traditional pharmaceuticals.”
Those who advocate for the cannabis industry in the region also maintain that domestic cultivation could generate employment for locals. But they warn, too, of the danger of exploitation. In its report, the CARICOM Commission advises that member states should be attuned to the “tensions between small local farmers and large enterprises, including foreign companies.” Small, landless farmers, it underscores, must be included in the development of land tenure and licensing strategies.
Additionally, to “safeguard our hegemony and future development interests,” the Commission suggested that industry development in the Caribbean region “should be premised on innovation and not unduly rely on the provision of raw products.”
Such a concern is shared by nations throughout the Americas. In Colombia, for instance, lawmakers solidified the country’s role in the global market by making it a point to craft a medical cannabis law that forced foreign companies to manufacture and innovate within its borders. In this way, they ensured that Colombia would not be reduced to solely exporting the raw material.
The CARICOM Commission’s report suggests similar measures, warning that the “Liberalisation and legal reform of marijuana cannot be undertaken in an ad hoc way, without a proper appreciation of the deep historical inequities between CARICOM states, as a group of underdeveloped, often exploited nation-states and companies from large, powerful nations interested in marijuana as an industry.”
In a section labeled “Unequal Trade Relationships and Foreign Control,” the report goes on to say that while multinational corporations can provide “significant capital investments,” they have a tendency to limit the transfer of knowledge and technology “in areas relating to production, processing, and research and development.” Caribbean governments, the Commission underscores, can ensure that policies encouraging such transfers are written into agreements with multinational corporations.
Moreover, given the unique strains of cannabis in the region, the commission encouraged officials to craft legislation that provides for the protection of seeds and strains “through intellectual property mechanisms.”
CARICOM, the report concludes, “must avoid the unequal paradigms that were experienced in other trade arrangements and learn lessons from historical experiences with other crops and indigenous services. These include sugar, cocoa, bananas, offshore finance, even tourism, all of which existed within predatory relationships and too little returns for CARICOM peoples.”
Shortly after Jamaica legalized medical cannabis, Verald Vassell, a renowned Rastafarian and cannabis activist commonly known as Ras Iyah V, made a similar point in an interview with The New York Times:
“If we are not organized, and are not helped, the possibility exists for the ganja industry to become the next tourism, coffee, or sugar industry,” he said, “where our people are used as common laborers and the wealth is confined to a few.”
The Canadian Factor
The foreign interest and investment that these Caribbean nations both hope for and worry about is already arriving, and it is largely coming from far to the north.
Since passing its amendment to the Dangerous Drugs Act in 2015, for example, Jamaica has seen an influx of Canadian influence. In September 2018, for instance, Timeless Herbal Care became the first Jamaican company to legally export cannabis, even though the Cannabis Licensing Authority has not finalized its export-import framework. Nevertheless, with the help of the Jamaican government, Timeless negotiated with Health Canada to export cannabis oil for an analysis of its chemical profile. (The process involved acquiring an import permit from Health Canada, along with an export permit from Jamaica’s Ministry of Health.)
Likewise, the Canadian-based Jamaica Medical Cannabis Corporation Ltd. signed an agreement to invest $2 million, over a span of ten years, to catalog and preserve the island’s native cannabis strains.
In an interview with Forbes, the company’s CEO, Diane Scott, said that “farmers will not be compensated for providing their heritage strains” and are expected to “share” them with Jamaica’s National Foundation for the Development of Science and Technology. At a cannabis expo in Toronto in June 2018, the company announced contracts to provide Jamaican cannabis to three Canadian limited partnerships, as well as letters of intent to supply seven more, all pending approval from Health Canada.
In February, Wiisag, a Canadian Indigenous cannabis company, announced a partnership with Jamaica’s Westmoreland Hemp and Ganja Farmers Association. According to the company, Wiisag will provide funding, services, and management for the association’s ten-acre pilot project to grow medical cannabis. The project was endorsed by activist Ras Iyah V, who previously warned against the exploitation of local farmers by foreign companies.
Jacana, which has ties with the UK and Canada, has also taken root in Jamaica. Founded in 2017, the company has established a 100-acre farm in Saint Ann, the largest parish in the country. In a March 2019 interview, founder Alexandra Chong said the company was “focused only on medical markets,” but she said she imagines that its brands “could be a good fit for the adult-use market down the line.”
Canadian influence has pushed beyond Jamaica, too. In 2018, a group from Canada advised Antigua and Barbuda on draft legislation involving adult use and medical cannabis. In a statement to Telesur, officials confirmed that its Cabinet met with the group to learn about “the kinds of steps required by the government of Antigua and Barbuda in order to make possible the growing, harvesting, processing, and sale of medical cannabis in its many forms.”
Likewise, David Burt, who serves as Bermuda’s Premier, held a highly publicized meeting last year with Bruce Linton, then-CEO of Canopy Growth Corporation. With a tweet, the premier welcomed Linton to the country, highlighting that the encounter took place following an announcement that Bermuda will establish a regime for the domestic production of medical cannabis. In one accompanying image, the caption reads: “We invite companies like Canopy to invest in local entrepreneurs to create more jobs & partnerships in Bermuda.”Laws are loosening and investors are interested, but who will reap the benefits?
Saint Lucia Considers the Economics of Cannabis Reform
An analysis presents a case for adult-use, among other reforms, as the country’s leaders consider how to shape legislation.
Published on Jul 9, 2020 6:55AM EDT Caribbean
Clydeen McDonald is a journalist based in Trinidad and Tobago.
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
- Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
- Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
National consultations on the cultivation of cannabis for domestic use and export are taking place in Saint Lucia, as the Caribbean country debates plans to diversify its agricultural industry. Saint Lucia is among an ever-shrinking group of countries in the Caribbean that have yet to enact cannabis reforms, either decriminalization or legalization for medical or adult use.
The consultations with stakeholders and the public come on the heels of a report shared last month with the country’s Cabinet of Ministers from the government-established Cannabis Commission, which explores “various models on the way forward” for cannabis reforms, including the introduction of adult-use provisions, according to Bradley Felix, the Minister for Commerce, Industry, Investment, Enterprise Development and Consumer Affairs.
“My colleagues have agreed that we are at a period where the approach must be different,” Felix told members of the House of Assembly on June 26, during the discussion of the country’s fiscal budget for 2020. “We have concluded that the criminalization of cannabis has been ineffective in reducing the use of cannabis,” he added, citing the significant economic and enforcement cost accrued annually.
Public comment during the consultation process, according to Felix, will influence the legislative drafting process. The panelists for this week’s consultation include Chairman of the Commission, Micheal Gordon, along with Stephen King, a health consultant working to formulate the reform policy. Since the Commission delivered its report, it has held four virtual consultations with various key stakeholder groups, including faith-based organizations, the National Youth Council, NGOs, and various government agencies.
The Commission’s report, titled “An Economic Analysis of the Regulation of the Cannabis Industry in Saint Lucia,” which has not yet been made public, comes just under a year after the government agreed to establish the Commission to review the impact of reforming the island’s current laws would have on its tourism-dependent economy. It puts everything, even adult-use cannabis legalization on the table, with an emphasis on domestic cultivation, along with incentive programs to pivot persons cultivating cannabis illicitly into the legal market.
The report, according to a statement shared with Cannabis Wire from the Office of the Prime Minister, provides “background and context, arguments against and for regulatory reform,” along with recommendations for “alternative regulatory models, economic assessment, cost-benefit analysis, and a macro-economic impact assessment” of legalization.
Under current law, Saint Lucia allows a judge to impose fines instead of imprisonment for cannabis-related crimes, but the existing fines, which can range up to $20,000 to avoid a five- to ten-year-year prison term, are prohibitively expensive, particularly for the persons of lower economic means who are frequently arrested.
If lawmakers take up the most extensive reforms presented in the analysis, Saint Lucia could join the Bahamas, Bermuda, and the US Virgin Islands as the only group of islands in the region to consider adult-use regulations. Other countries in the region, as Cannabis Wire has reported, have moved toward decriminalization and the legalization of medical cannabis. An effort to legalize cannabis for adult use failed to gain approval in the British Virgin Islands last week, and, as Cannabis Wire reported, only medical use moved forward.
The most recent polling conducted on the island by the Caribbean Development Research Services, also known as CADRES, suggests local legislators could see public support for reforms. Of the 1,000 persons interviewed by CADRES in Saint Lucia, 51% of the population support cannabis-related legislative reform with just 38% wishing to maintain the status quo. Peter Wickham, a regional political consultant and the director of CADRES, told Cannabis Wire that he believes “public opinion” is trending in this direction, in part due to the perceived economic incentives many people associate with the industry.
Reform advocates are hoping that widespread public support will lead to a “definitive change this year,” Andre de Caires, a member of Saint Lucia’s Cannabis Commission, told Cannabis Wire.
“Many of us feel confident after the meeting that the government will strongly consider the report,” said de Caires, who is also the Chairman of the Cannabis Movement, a group of local cannabis activists.
Stakeholder groups—including the Cannabis Movement, the Iyanola Council for the Advancement of Rastafari, the National Youth Council, the Saint Lucia Christian Council, and the Saint Lucia Industrial and Small Business Association—were represented on the country’s Cannabis Commission and contributed to the report.
Support also extends to members of the country’s business community and its national investment promotion agency, Invest Saint Lucia. The Agency’s CEO, Roderick Cherry, told local journalists last year that “a legalized, well-regulated and well-run cannabis industry” will have a significant economic impact on Saint Lucia, should such an industry be created.
During the budget debate in June, the country’s opposition leader, Philip Pierre, also reiterated his support in a national address, saying: “We believe that it is time for a conclusion and closure on this issue while ensuring that the people who suffered prosecution — Rastafarians — benefit from any decision on cannabis use. This is not a time for politics but reconciliation, good sense and protection of health and livelihoods.”
Pierre, also called for the agricultural sector to be involved in the business of cannabis production for economic and medical reasons, along with the “expungement of records for cannabis-related criminal activity for small quantities of cannabis.”
The Prime Minister, Allen Chastanet, has also weighed in on the “discussion taking place” on the island recently. At the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank Monetary Council in February, he highlighted the need to provide opportunities to the country’s citizens, with an eye toward domestic cultivation and export.
“Are we going to allow foreign investors to come in where our farmers are going to be used as workers, or are we going to be in the production of the product ourselves,” he asked.
“When it comes to cannabis,” Chastanet has said the government is seeking to focus on value-added and pharmaceutical products as opposed to simply producing inputs. Those products he explained will allow for “greater economic opportunity” for the island.An analysis presents a case for adult-use, among other reforms, as the country’s leaders consider how to shape legislation. ]]>